Midnight Fantasy [The Doms of Sybaris Cove 6] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting) Read online

  Before the contractions ended, Javier sunk his cock into her wetness, and she clung to Garrett as Javier fucked her deeply and slowly.

  Garrett straightened up and moved to the side, gazing toward Javier. “That is really hot to watch, but I hope we’re taking turns.”

  Javier brushed his hands over her legs and abdomen. “That’s up to Renata.”

  She laughed again and stretched her arms overhead. “Oh, yes. Please. Fuck me. Both of you. Every which way and in every hole. All night long.”

  They actually high-fived each other, and now she really couldn’t stop laughing. She’d never been this contented.

  “Your wish is our command,” said Javier.

  Chapter Eight

  Javier’s head was still reeling from the fact he was here, in his house, fucking Renata. That Garrett was all over her boobs was immaterial. Once they’d started playing, all his discomfort and uncertainty at sharing this experience with his friend had melted away. There wouldn’t have been any other workable solution. It had to be this way. He’d not only forgiven Renata for the way she’d acted all those years ago, but his heart had gone out to her when she’d found out earlier about her ancestor’s sacrifice.

  His own family had done that. And yet here she was, with both of them, giving herself first in play to them, and now this. It was too much to take in, so he stopped trying and instead enjoyed the tightness of her pussy and the way his whole body trembled every time she moaned.

  Garrett finally came up for air and asked if they could switch. Javier really didn’t want to, but fair was fair, so he pulled out and moved to where he could reach her face. As Garrett plunged his dick into her pussy, Javier kissed her, grasping her breasts in his hands as he did so. Now that she was here, he never wanted to let her leave this house.

  He had no clue how this was going to work, or if it would, but they were here now. That’s all that mattered. And she loved impact play, which was his favorite thing in the whole world. All those years he’d spent being angry at her faded away as he gazed into her beautiful dark eyes. He’d waited a long time to see such tenderness and longing on her face, and he was going to do everything in his power to make sure she always felt this way toward him.

  * * * *

  Renata could hardly breathe. Having them both here, taking turns fucking her, was overwhelming, but in a good way. In the best way possible. And the way Javier was gazing at her right now brought back so many memories that she almost couldn’t handle it. But it would be all right. They’d agreed the past was behind them, so that’s where it needed to stay. She could still hardly believe all she’d experienced with them tonight, and the evening wasn’t over.

  She ran her hands all over Javier’s body, loving the way his muscles rippled underneath her fingers. Garrett’s cock inside her pussy felt so damn incredible that an unprecedented third climax was building. Javier’s cock looked ready to explode, and she licked her lips. “May I suck you while he fucks me?”

  “Oh God…” Javier’s voice actually trembled. He moved closer to her face and turned hers toward him, gently cupping it while he guided his cock into her mouth. She wrapped her hands around the base and took as much of it into her mouth as she could, moaning at the fullness.

  “Jesus Christ,” whispered Garrett. “Talk about fucking hot to watch.”

  His words threatened to bring on another giggling fit, so instead she concentrated on licking Javier’s dick and his balls, alternating that with sucking. The combination of having both men inside her was incredible, and when she came, she took care not to accidentally bite him.

  Garrett withdrew and moved to the other side of her face. She wasn’t sure Javier could hang on long enough to switch, and her suspicions were correct when he grasped her head and pushed his cock deeper into her mouth. He cried out loudly as he fucked it rough and deep, but Renata didn’t mind. When hot cum filled her mouth, she swallowed every tasty drop.

  Garrett played with her breasts until Javier finally pulled out, and then Renata didn’t wait for Garrett to ask. She turned her head toward him and opened her mouth.

  “God… oh God… thank you…”

  It didn’t take long for Garrett to come in her mouth, and she tried to swallow all of his cum as well, but some dribbled down her chin. Once he finished, he fell back against the slate and lay there, breathing hard. Renata glanced toward Javier, who watched her with a grin on his face.

  “I think we need to get someplace more comfortable.”

  “I agree.” She stood and looked around for her clothes, then scooped them up and headed for the stairs, but Javier stopped her. He put his arms around her and held her close.

  “Thank you so much for this.”

  “No, thank you. Both of you.” She pulled away so she could look into his eyes. “For everything, not just the play and the sex. For giving me another chance, and for being there tonight when Petra told us about Faith.”

  Javier stroked her hair gently. “I know that wasn’t easy to hear.”

  “But I would have found out eventually. I’m just glad I was with you two when I did.”

  Garrett was on his feet now, and he sighed out loud. “Fuck. Who’s going to carry this damn mattress back downstairs?”

  Renata chuckled. “I’ll help you two big strong men carry it.”

  * * * *

  Garrett and Javier had insisted on moving the mattress without Renata’s help, but halfway down the stairs, Garrett wished they’d taken her up on the offer. They had a more difficult time getting the mattress back into one of the spare bedrooms than they’d had carrying it up the stairs. Then again, they’d both just been given fucking exquisite blow jobs, so that was as good an excuse as any.

  Once they had it back on the bed and had retrieved their clothes, the toys, condoms, and lube from the tower room, they went in search of Renata. They found her in Javier’s bathroom, standing under the shower spray with her eyes closed.

  “What a great idea,” said Garrett.

  She opened her eyes and smiled at them. “What took you so long?”

  He shook his head as he stepped inside, followed by Javier. “She’s really quite mouthy, isn’t she?”

  “I agree. Not very sub-like at all.”

  “Is that what I am now? Your sub?”

  “Not with that attitude,” said Garrett, moving her from under the spray to back her up against a wall. He pulled her arms overhead and held her wrists with one hand. She moaned softly and gave him that look. It was enough to make him weak in the knees all over again, and much to his delight, his dick began to twitch.

  Javier was at her side, stroking her breasts. “How shall we teach her a lesson?”

  “Well, I don’t know. She’s been spanked, paddled, and flogged, and it doesn’t seem to have helped.”

  “And we’ve fucked her pussy and her mouth.” Javier brushed two fingers over her lips, and she moaned louder. “There’s only one thing I can think to do. The ultimate submission. But will she do it?”

  Garrett’s dick was rock hard now. He felt like a teenager again, when all it had taken was the mere thought of a naked girl to get a boner. Especially this naked girl. Renata had always been the woman who starred in all his daydreams and wet dreams. But the reality of being with her was more than he’d ever been able to conjure up in any fantasy. And it wasn’t only her body and the way she’d given it to them both tonight. It was all of her. Her humor, the way she looked at every new thing with curiosity and wonder, and that look in her eyes when he’d finally taken her.

  He’d waited years to gaze into her eyes again. The fact that Javier was also here tonight, experiencing this along with him, was fine. Garrett would share her if he had to, but he would never, ever let her get away again, no matter what he had to do to keep her.

  * * * *

  Renata waited, knowing what they were going to ask her to do. She could hardly take a full breath now. She was so turned-on it was ridiculous. Once upon a time she’d had fantasie
s of making love to both men at the same time, but the reality of doing it had blown those out of the water.

  “We have no choice,” said Javier, tugging her hair. “We have to teach you a lesson.”

  She groaned out loud, not because it hurt, but because the gesture was so dominant and damn sexy that she nearly came again. “What are you going to do to me?”

  Javier nuzzled her neck, and his breath was hot against her ear. “Fuck you in the ass, love. Taking turns. And you’re going to take it.” He reached behind her and gave her left ass cheek a good, hard smack. “Because you are a very, very bad girl.”

  She hoped they didn’t expect her to answer, because right now it wasn’t even possible to think. Garrett let go of her wrists and then they stepped out of the shower. He led her to Javier’s bed and told her to lean over it. She obeyed without question. It was impossible not to. She wanted this so badly and wasn’t the least bit afraid. She knew they’d be careful. She trusted them both without reservation.

  Garrett moved behind her and massaged her breasts. Javier crossed to the other side of the room, and Garrett moaned loudly as he pushed his dick up against her ass crack. “Renata, I hope you’re enjoying this as much as we both are.”

  “I love it. Honestly. I had no idea you two were so sexy. This is perfect. Thank you.”

  “No, thank you.” He kissed her lower back. “For everything.”

  Javier placed the bottle of lube and the box of condoms on the bed next to her. “See those? We’re going to use them both up tonight, bad girl.”

  She giggled. “Uh-oh. I’m in trouble.”

  “Yes you are.” Javier reached underneath to stroke her clit, while Garrett reached for the bottle of lube.

  Renata held her breath. She’d never had anal sex. Should she tell them that? Both men stopped touching her long enough to each put on a condom, and then a warm, wet finger slid into her asshole.

  “Keep breathing, sweetheart.” Garrett’s voice was gentle, coaxing, and it nearly brought tears to her eyes. She’d been right. They would never hurt her. At first, his finger inside burned, but then the only sensation was pressure. Once she grew used to it, it was quite pleasurable.

  Javier kissed her neck, and then leaned underneath her body to lick her nipples. Garrett caressed her clit as he moved his finger in and out of her asshole. “Do you like this?” he asked.

  “Yes…oh, yes.”

  Garrett withdrew his finger, and when he entered her again, this time it was with two fingers. He stretched the walls, coaxing her as before. The combination of both men touching her breasts and clit while her asshole was teased at the same time sent Renata into a blissful state once more. This was the ultimate surrender. Javier hadn’t been exaggerating about that.

  When Garrett removed his fingers again, she tensed. They must have noticed it, because Javier placed one finger against her chin and turned her head to face him. “It’s all right. We won’t hurt you. I promise. Just keep breathing. And if you really can’t handle it, just say so and we stop. Okay?”

  She nodded. “Okay. Thank you.”

  His eyes went all soft, and she sighed out loud. “No, sweetheart. Thank you. For all of this.”

  That did it. Renata took several deep breaths and readjusted her feet to brace herself. When Garrett’s dick slid into her asshole, it didn’t hurt at all. She could tell he’d used more lube, because it was so easy. There was pressure, but once she grew used to that again and he began to thrust, she moaned loudly as wave after wave of desire crashed over her.

  Javier whispered encouraging words in her ear as he teased her nipples and her clit. Renata couldn’t believe it when she came again. The climax wasn’t as strong as the earlier ones, but it still felt pretty fucking good. It wasn’t quite done when Garrett pulled out and Javier took his place.

  He fucked her ass a bit rougher than Garrett had done, but she didn’t mind. This was exquisite and she loved it. Garrett rubbed her clit and nipples until she could hardly stand it, and then Javier pulled out.

  “I need to fuck hard,” he said, his voice rough. “And I don’t want to hurt you.” She heard him take off his condom. “We’re going to fuck your pussy again.” He gave her ass cheeks a hard smack, and she cried out in pleasure. “Hard and deep.”

  Renata lowered her torso onto the bed as Garrett stepped behind her. He removed his condom as well, and then Javier plunged his cock into her pussy. It was already tender from before, but she didn’t even care. This was what she wanted. To be taken by both these sexy, strong men.

  “Renata…you feel so damn good!” He slammed into her without mercy, and she cried out as the contractions from her orgasm went on and on. When he came, he cried out as well, and then Garrett was inside her pussy again, fucking her just as passionately as Javier had.

  Once he finished, he kissed both ass cheeks, her lower back, and then worked his way up to her neck. “Thank you. Thank you so much.”

  Renata could barely think, let alone speak. She’d never imagined such a fun, erotic night like this. So many new experiences, and finally the one she’d longed for with both men. To make love to them. She’d have done that in high school if their relationships had gone that far, but none of that mattered now.

  She was here, with them, and they’d shared so much. They crawled onto the bed and Renata snuggled against Garrett’s warm body in front, while Javier nestled up against her from behind. Renata drifted off to sleep with a smile on her face, sore but totally sated and happier than she’d ever been.

  Chapter Nine

  Renata woke up Saturday to the smell of grits and shrimp. Javier and Garrett weren’t in the room. She crawled out of bed and used the bathroom, and then she glanced around for her clothes. Javier came in, whistling a Bach tune. “There she is.” He pulled her into his arms. “We have a feast ready for you this morning.”

  She smiled. “Do I really smell shrimp and grits? Who eats that for breakfast?”

  “Ah…people in Louisiana do.”

  “We’re not in Louisiana.”

  “We’re close enough.” He kissed her. “I have a T-shirt and shorts you can put on if you want. Then we’ll take you home so you can grab some things and stay here all weekend with us.”

  “Is that what I’m doing?”

  He nuzzled her neck. “Please say yes.”

  Renata moaned softly. “How could I say no to either of you?”

  Javier pumped his fist in the air. “Yes! Our plan worked.”

  She laughed. “Oh, I see. That’s how it is. Seduce me and then kidnap me.”

  “Yeah, I guess we sort of reversed that, didn’t we?”

  She snuggled back against his warm body. “I’m here willingly.”

  He kissed her again. “I sure hope so. Come on. I’m starving, and Garrett is a fabulous cook.”

  “Please tell me there’s coffee, too.”

  “I made that. It’s my specialty. I can plug in a coffee maker and turn it on like no one’s business.”

  “A true gourmet. I’m half in love already.”

  He stared at her so intently she wished she hadn’t let that particular quip get out. But then he smiled again and led her downstairs.

  Garrett had not only made shrimp and grits, but there were fried eggs and toast, as well. Renata ate like she hadn’t seen food in a week. “What have you two done to me? I hardly ever eat breakfast.”

  “We fucked you a lot,” said Garrett, shoveling food into his mouth.

  “It was the paddling,” said Javier. “It ramps up your need for food.”

  She laughed so hard she nearly choked. “At least you’re honest. I’ll give you that.”

  “It’s true,” said Javier. “Healthy play and sex gives you a huge appetite. Wear it proudly, Renata.”

  Garrett asked if she was comfortable talking about what Petra had told them all last night, or if she’d rather not discuss it.

  “No, it’s all right. It was a shock, but I don’t know why I should be surprised
.” She put her hand to her mouth at the looks on their faces. “Oh my God, I didn’t mean it like that. I meant this whole curse thing is crazy, and it shouldn’t surprise any of us that human sacrifice was involved. Your great-grandfathers died trying to leave this island. Isn’t that also a sacrifice of sorts?”

  They both nodded. “True,” said Garrett. “I totally agree. And don’t forget about Daniel, Tim’s father. He died trying to leave, too.”

  “I didn’t know that.”

  Javier nodded. “Yes. And he’s not the only one from that generation to try it. They didn’t make it, either.”

  She took a bite of toast. “Do you think Petra can actually lift it?”

  “I think so,” said Garret. “She certainly sounds like she knows what she’s talking about.”

  “I wonder who this friend is from St. Croix she’s asking to come here.”

  “Whoever he is, it sounds as though she has complete faith in him,” said Javier. “That’s more than we’ve ever had before.”

  After they finished eating, Renata insisted on helping them with the dishes, and then Javier took her home so she could shower and grab some clothes and other personal items. He waited for her, after telling her he’d rather shower with her. She suggested they all do that later since it was so much fun last night, and then she fantasized about fucking them in the shower.

  When she was finally ready, all she wanted to do was jump Javier. She couldn’t remember being this horny in a long, long time. Even as sore and tired as she was, she was ready to go again once they returned to Javier’s home.

  Garrett was in the media room on the lower level, watching the news. They joined him, and when a commercial aired featuring a classical music piece, she asked Javier if she could see his cello.

  “Do you just want to see it, or would you like to hear me play?”

  She laughed and hit him playfully on the arm. “You’re such a smart-ass.”